TSP vs 401k: Which Builds More Retirement Money

By Apex Reign · Published 2026-11-18

TSP vs 401(k): The Decision at a Glance

Servicemembers and veterans eventually hit the same fork in the road everyone else does: your government TSP account versus the 401(k) waiting at your civilian employer. Both are tax-advantaged retirement accounts. Both follow generous contribution limits. But the differences - costs, fund choices, employer matching, and what happens when you leave the service - decide which one deserves your money first.

The short version: the TSP is the cheapest retirement plan in America, and if you are still in uniform, its 5% match under the Blended Retirement System is free money no 401(k) should make you pass up. The 401(k) wins on fund variety and flexibility once you are out of uniform or chasing bigger employer contributions. Run the real numbers in our military pay calculator to see how much of your paycheck each option leaves you.

The TSP: What It Is and Why the Costs Are Unbeatable

The Thrift Savings Plan is the federal government's version of a 401(k), open to uniformed servicemembers and federal employees. It offers five core index funds: two stock funds (C and S), an international fund (I), a bond fund (F), and a treasury fund (G). The Lifecycle (L) funds mix those five automatically based on your target retirement date.

What makes the TSP famous is its expense ratios. Those funds cost a fraction of what most 401(k) plans charge. Industry analyses consistently rank TSP fees among the lowest in the country. On a $100,000 balance, the difference between a 0.05% fee and a 1% fee is roughly $950 a year - every year - and that compounds. Over a 30-year career, high fees can quietly eat six figures out of your retirement balance.

The 401(k): Matching Power and Fund Choice

A civilian 401(k) lives and dies by one number: the employer match. Average matching contributions across private industry run roughly 3.5% to 4.5% of salary when fully vested. Some plans stretch to 6% or more. If your employer matches, that match is an instant return no index fund can offer.

The 401(k) also opens a fund menu most TSP investors never see: target-date families, sector funds, REITs, and sometimes a self-directed brokerage window. Fees vary wildly by employer - small-company plans can be notoriously expensive, while plans at large companies rival the TSP. Read your plan's fee disclosure before assuming anything.

Contribution Limits: Nearly Identical

Both plans follow the same IRS rules. The employee deferral limit is the same for the TSP and a 401(k) in a given year. The age-50 catch-up contribution applies to both. You can hold both: a servicemember with self-employment or other civilian earned income can contribute to both a TSP and a 401(k), but the combined employee deferral limit applies across both plans.

The Match: Up to 5 Percent in Uniform, Depends in a 401(k)

Under the Blended Retirement System (BRS), the government matches your TSP contributions up to 5% of basic pay after you are vested - 1% automatic plus up to 4% matched. Opting out of that match is declining a raise. If you are in BRS, fund the TSP to at least 5% before anything else goes anywhere.

A 401(k) match depends entirely on your employer. If a civilian employer matches at 6% or better, that beat can outweigh the TSP's fee advantage in the early years. If they match nothing, the TSP's fees and simplicity usually win.

Portability: What Happens When You Move

When you leave the military, your TSP comes with you - it never has to be rolled over. You can leave it, roll it into an IRA or a civilian 401(k), or keep contributing under the special limits that apply to separated participants. That optionality is a quiet advantage: leaving your TSP alone preserves its low fees forever.

A civilian 401(k) typically must be rolled out - to an IRA or the next employer's plan - when you change jobs, unless your balance is large enough to stay. Every rollover is an opportunity for fees and mistakes if done sloppily, so plan them deliberately.

Head-to-Head Comparison

FactorTSP401(k)
CostsAmong the lowest anywhereVaries by employer, often higher
MatchUp to 5% under BRSDepends on employer
Fund choices5 index funds + L fundsUsually much broader
Portability when leavingStays with you, no rushUsually rolled over
LoansAvailable with rulesPlan-dependent
Roth optionYes (Roth TSP)Usually (plan-dependent)

What Most People Should Actually Do

In uniform: capture the full BRS match first - TSP to 5%, everything else second. Out of uniform: fund whatever plan carries a match up to the match, then compare fees and fund quality between your old TSP and your new 401(k) for every additional dollar. When the 401(k) is expensive or thin on choices, push past the match into the TSP; when the 401(k) is cheap and matching is strong, let the 401(k) lead.

High-income households have one more lever: Roth contributions. The Roth TSP and Roth 401(k) both allow tax-free growth, and the right mix depends on whether you expect a higher or lower bracket in retirement - a question worth running against your projected pension and pay trajectory in our calculator.

BRS Reminder: This Comparison Depends on Your Era

Servicemembers who opted into BRS (or joined after January 1, 2018) get the TSP match. Those grandfathered into the legacy High-3 system receive no match, which flips the comparison on its head: with no match on the line, the TSP's appeal is purely its low-cost index funds, and a strong civilian 401(k) match deserves a serious look during and after service.

Bottom Line

There is no universal winner. In-uniform, the BRS match makes the TSP the first dollar destination. Out of uniform, follow the match and the fees - not the brand names. And if you are weighing how much of your drill pay or base pay you can actually spare every month, that number starts with the paycheck: run it through the military pay calculator first.

FAQ

Can I contribute to both a TSP and a 401(k) at the same time?

Yes, if you have eligible earned income from both service and civilian work. The annual employee deferral limit applies across both accounts combined, so track your total contributions if you split money between them.

Should I roll my TSP into my 401(k) when I leave the military?

Not automatically. You can leave the TSP open indefinitely. Compare fees and fund menus before rolling anything; a high-cost 401(k) may be worse than keeping the TSP untouched.

Does the TSP cost more than a good 401(k)?

Rarely. The TSP's expense ratios are among the lowest available and typically beat employer 401(k) plans, which often carry 1% or more in blended fees.

What is the TSP match under BRS?

The government contributes an automatic 1% after two years of service and dollar-for-dollar matching up to an additional 4% - 5% total when you contribute 5% of your own basic pay.

Do TSP and 401(k) have the same limits?

The employee deferral limit is identical because the IRS sets it for both plan types. Catch-up contributions at age 50 work the same way.

📧 Free: The Military Pay Toolkit (PDF)

2026 rates, allowances, and the moves that raise your take-home pay — BAH, TSP, W-4, and special pays. No spam, one click to leave.

Double opt-in: you'll get a confirmation email first. Unsubscribe anytime.